Expert Legal Recruiters for Attorneys & Lawyers | BCG Attorney Search

Search Insights & Resources

Search Attorney Jobs

Interview Preparation Techniques

Introduction

Most attorneys believe that strong credentials alone will carry them through an interview. They’re wrong. The truth is that interviews are not about your résumé—they’re about how well you can connect with the interviewer, anticipate their concerns, and present yourself as someone who will thrive inside their firm. Over the years, I’ve seen countless talented attorneys lose opportunities simply because they failed to prepare the right way. Mastering interview preparation techniques is what separates the candidates who get offers from those who are quietly rejected. In this guide, I’ll walk you through the strategies top attorneys use to excel in interviews—researching firms effectively, mastering tough behavioral questions, refining your narrative, and building the confidence that law firms want to see.

Highly Recommended Video:

Watch Harrison Barnes share essential legal interview preparation strategies that can significantly improve your performance and help you stand out to law firms. This short video is a must-see before you begin your interview preparation.

Why Most Attorneys Screw Up Interviews and Their Legal Careers

1. The Truth About Law Firm Interviews

When a law firm is interviewing you, they want to hire you.

  • They have already invested money and time in the process.
  • If you perform well, you have a 90% chance of moving forward to the next interview and eventually getting an offer.
  • They don’t want you to fail—they need you.

Yet, most attorneys still blow it. They walk away underemployed, rejected, and stuck in stalled careers.


2. Why Attorneys Fail Interviews

The biggest mistake attorneys make is focusing on themselves instead of the firm.

  • It’s not about what you want (remote work, higher salary, prestige).
  • It’s about what the firm needs—and whether you can meet those needs.
  • Ego, entitlement, and self-focus sink more interviews than lack of qualifications.

Law firms reject people who come across as arrogant or self-serving. They hire those who show they will serve, learn, and contribute.


3. What Law Firms Actually Care About

A law firm interviewing you is looking for someone who:

  • Understands the firm, the role, and the people
  • Wants to be in the city and practice area long-term
  • Will be loyal, manageable, and teachable
  • Respects the attorneys interviewing them
  • Shows humility and eagerness to work hard

They are not interested in:

  • Your demands for remote work or higher pay
  • Your “unique” story or inflated self-perception
  • Why you think the firm isn’t good enough for you

4. The Winning Interview Mindset

The best attorneys understand that interviewing is a form of selling:

  • Convincing clients to hire them
  • Persuading judges to see their side
  • Negotiating deals

The interview is your chance to sell yourself. Winners always:

  • See things from others’ perspectives
  • Flatter and respect interviewers
  • Act humble and eager
  • Put service above ego

Even a $700,000/year partner could convince a small-town firm to hire them for $65,000/year—because they know how to make the interviewer feel respected, needed, and valued.


5. The Ego Trap

  • Top law school grads and BigLaw associates are often the worst interviewers because they let ego drive the conversation.
  • Early career years are about training, mentorship, and growth—not money or prestige.
  • Interviewers want to help those who show respect and loyalty, not arrogance.

Remember: the person across the table has likely survived 10, 20, or 30 years in the profession. That alone deserves respect.


6. What Successful Attorneys Do

The most successful attorneys—those making $5M+ a year—don’t flaunt ego. They:

  • Serve clients, firms, and the profession humbly
  • Avoid arrogance, ostentation, or anything that creates resentment
  • Focus entirely on giving others what they need

This is why they win. This is why they keep advancing.


7. The Rule of Job Offers

You cannot negotiate until you get the offer.

  • First, meet the firm’s needs.
  • Then, once they want you, they will go out of their way to meet your needs.
  • This is how business works: service first, rewards after.

Understand this, and your career will never be the same.


8. Final Word of Advice

If you truly want to succeed in interviews—and in your legal career—start here:

Law firms hire soldiers, not generals. The generals of tomorrow are the soldiers who prove themselves today.

BCG Attorney Search Interview Preparation Guide

Introduction

This guide is designed to help you excel in your interviews with law firms. The ultimate goal is to progress to the next stage of the interview process and ultimately receive an offer. Remember, if a firm has decided to interview you, they are interested in hiring you. Below, we've outlined key strategies for both Zoom and in-person interviews, along with essential questions and preparation tips to make a strong impression.

Zoom Interviews: The Essentials

  • Camera Positioning: Ensure your camera is directly facing you; this is crucial for making a personal connection.
  • Dress Code: Wear business attire to convey professionalism, even in a virtual setting.
  • Background: Have a neutral background (a solid color is best) and try not to show your home or workspace.

In-Person Interviews: Making an Impression

  • Appearance: Dress sharply and look your best.
  • Engagement: Maintain eye contact and have a printed copy of your resume on hand.

Understanding Your Interviewers

  • Research: Before the interview, read the bios of the attorneys you'll be meeting. Understand their area of practice and current projects.
  • Common Ground: Identify and discuss any similarities in your work and theirs to establish rapport.

Discussing Your Career Move

  • Why Are You Looking?: Be prepared to discuss why you're seeking a new opportunity.
  • Salary Expectations: A diplomatic response would be, "I expect to be compensated similarly to my peers within your firm or similar firms."
  • Remote Work: Express flexibility, indicating you're willing to adapt to the firm's needs, whether remote or in-person.

The Five Key Questions Interviewers Have

  1. Can You Do the Job?
    • Understand what the firm is looking for and articulate how your skills and experience align with their needs. If there's something you're not familiar with, express your willingness and ability to learn.
  2. Will You Commit to the Job?
    • Convey stability and long-term interest in the position. Share any relevant experiences that demonstrate your loyalty and dedication to past roles.
  3. Con You Be Managed?
    • Acknowledge the expectations of billable hours and your readiness to meet them, showing you're manageable and committed.
  4. Do You Want The Job?
    • Demonstrate enthusiasm for the role and the firm. Explain why you believe it's a good fit for your career goals.
  5. Do We Like You??
    • Build a connection with the interviewers. Being personable and showing vulnerability can make you more relatable and likable.

Additional Questions to Consider in an Interview

When interviewing, your questions should always reflect how you can contribute value to the firm—never what the firm can do for you. Avoid asking about vacation, health insurance, remote work, compensation, or any benefits. These issues can be addressed later in the process if appropriate.

Instead, focus your questions on how you can meet the needs of the attorneys and the firm. Your questions should communicate initiative, humility, and a service-oriented mindset.

Smart Questions to Ask:

  1. Performance Expectations “What would success in this position look like in the first 30, 60, and 90 days? What would I need to do to become one of your top hires?”
  2. Immediate Contribution “What is the most pressing need that I could help you with right now? Is there anything that is currently not getting done that I could take ownership of?”
  3. Firm Culture & Alignment “What aspects of working at this firm do you enjoy the most? From what you’ve heard about my background, do you see areas where my past experiences or aspirations align with those same qualities?”
  4. Closing with Enthusiasm When you’ve asked your questions and there is a natural pause, it is often powerful to close with a short statement of commitment, such as: “I just want you to know that this is the sort of position I am truly looking for. I would very much appreciate the opportunity to work here, and I promise I will work hard to give you what you need and contribute as much value as possible.”

Weak Questions to Avoid — and Better Alternatives

Firms are evaluating whether you will put their clients first and add value to the team. If your questions suggest you are more focused on perks or convenience than on performance and contribution, you risk sending the wrong signal.

Here’s how to turn weak questions into strong ones:

Weak Question (Avoid)

  • “What is the vacation policy?”
  • “How much will I be paid as an associate?”
  • “Does the firm cover health insurance or gym memberships?”
  • “Can I work from home?”
  • “How late do associates usually have to stay?”
  • “Is weekend work required?”
  • “When would I be considered for partnership?”
  • “Can I bring in my own clients right away?”
  • “Do you reimburse commuting costs?”

Better Alternative (Ask Instead)

  • “What’s the typical workload like for someone in this role, and how can I best manage my time to exceed expectations?”
  • “What qualities do your top associates share that have helped them advance quickly here?”
  • “What kinds of professional development or training opportunities are available to help associates add more value to clients?”
  • “How can I best integrate into the team’s workflow so I’m available and responsive when needed?”
  • “What do your most successful associates do to manage demanding schedules while keeping client service strong?”
  • “What can I do to be the kind of associate you rely on when urgent matters arise?”
  • “What do partners here typically look for in associates who want to take on more responsibility over time?”
  • “How do associates typically get opportunities to contribute to business development efforts as they grow?”
  • “What is the best way for me to be present and accessible so I can contribute fully to the team?”

When It Is Appropriate to Ask About Salary, Benefits, and Logistics

  • After an Offer Is Made: Once the firm has decided they want you, you are in a position to clarify details about compensation, benefits, vacation, remote work, and other logistical matters. At that stage, asking is expected and professional.
  • If the Firm Brings It Up First: If an interviewer directly raises compensation, benefits, or logistics, it is appropriate to respond, but you should keep your answers professional and concise.
  • Through Your Recruiter: If you are working with BCG Attorney Search, your recruiter can handle many of these conversations on your behalf—so you remain focused on showing enthusiasm for the work and the opportunity.

Golden Rule: Until you have an offer in hand, every question you ask should emphasize what you can do for the firm, not what the firm can do for you.

Conclusion

Interview success hinges on preparation, understanding the firm and the interviewers, and effectively communicating your value and compatibility with the position. By following this guide, you'll be wellequipped to make a compelling case for why you're the right candidate for the job.

ADDITIONAL INTERVIEW RESOURCES:

Interview Preparation & Strategies

These resources emphasize the importance of preparation and offer insights into refining your interview skills to stand out.

  1. The Importance of Interview Preparation — No Matter How Confident You Feel About Your Interviewing Skills Emphasizes the necessity of thorough preparation, regardless of confidence level. Offers practical advice on handling common interview questions and managing nervous habits.
  2. Mastering the Interview Process: Insights from the BCG Attorney Search Interview Preparation Guide Offers comprehensive strategies for both Zoom and in-person interviews, emphasizing the importance of understanding the firm, preparing thoughtful questions, and demonstrating enthusiasm.
  3. Interview Preparation Techniques Provides practical techniques for preparing for interviews, including common questions to anticipate and strategies to present oneself effectively.
  4. BigLaw Interview Tips and Law Firm Interview Preparation Offers guidance for candidates interviewing with large law firms, highlighting the importance of preparation and understanding the firm's culture and expectations.
  5. Top 23 Law Firm Interview Tips: How to Excel in Law Firm Interviews Offers a comprehensive list of tips covering attire, communication, and etiquette to excel in law firm interviews.
  6. Top 10 Interview Questions During Your Law Firm Interview Outlines the 10 most commonly asked questions in law firm interviews and how to effectively prepare for them.
  7. The Best Interview Tips For Your Law Firm Interview Provides essential tips on how to present yourself confidently and professionally during law firm interviews.
  8. Top 23 Law Firm Interview Tips for Attorneys and Law Students: How to Excel in Law Firm Interviews Offers a comprehensive list of tips for law firm interviews, specifically tailored for attorneys and law students.

Interview Techniques & Communication

These articles dive deeper into specific strategies for effectively answering questions and navigating the interview process.

  1. The Art of Interviewing: Tips for Converting Interviews into Offers Provides strategies for engaging interviewers, showcasing enthusiasm, and effectively answering questions to increase the likelihood of receiving job offers.
  2. How Attorneys Should Answer the 'Tell Me About Yourself' Interview Question Guides attorneys on structuring their responses to this common question, focusing on aligning personal experiences with the firm's values and needs.
  3. Be Prepared For Every Interview: Practice Discussing Everything On Your Resume Stresses the necessity of being able to discuss all experiences listed on your resume with ease, ensuring you can confidently address any topic that arises during the interview.
  4. Off-the-Record Interview Tips from Law Firm Interviewers Shares candid advice from interviewers on how candidates can make a positive impression, covering aspects like punctuality, attire, and interpersonal skills.
  5. The Secret to Effectively Sharing Concerns About Your Current Employer Without Committing the Most Common Interview Blunder Gives advice on how to address concerns about your current employer without making a negative impression during an interview.

Post-Interview Etiquette & Follow-Up

These resources highlight the importance of post-interview communication, from thank-you notes to handling delays in feedback.

  1. Post Law Firm Interview: Don't Forget Your Thank You Notes! Explains the importance of sending thank-you notes after an interview and how to make your note stand out.
  2. Had a Great Interview but Have Got No Response to My Thank-You Emails Explains what to do when you've had a great interview but have not received any response to your thank-you emails.
  3. What Does It Mean If I Haven't Heard From a Law Firm After an Application/Interview? Discusses the possible reasons why you might not have heard back from a law firm after an interview or application.

Specific Interview Types & Situations

These articles address unique types of interviews and strategies for navigating them successfully.

  1. What to Wear to a Lunch Interview With a Law Firm Provides advice on the appropriate attire for a lunch interview with a law firm, emphasizing professionalism.
  2. How to Conduct Yourself During a Lunch Interview Provides key tips on how to behave during a lunch interview with a law firm to ensure you leave a positive impression.
  3. Why Most Attorneys and Law Students Fail Law Firm Telephone Screening Interviews Discusses common pitfalls in telephone screening interviews and offers strategies to succeed in them.
  4. How Attorneys Can Excel in Second Round Law Firm Interviews and Get More Job Offers Provides insights into what to do and what not to do in second-round interviews to increase job offers.