Expert Legal Recruiters for Attorneys & Lawyers | BCG Attorney Search

Search Insights & Resources

Search Attorney Jobs

Top Ten Reasons Attorneys Do Not Approve Firms — And How to Fix Each One

A comprehensive, data‑driven guide to overcoming the most common blockers to interviews and offers — and how BCG’s system turns approvals into results.

Contents

Executive Summary

Approving firms is the single most controllable predictor of your search outcome. Attorneys who approve broadly — or enable Mass Approval — access the hidden market, move faster than competing candidates, and convert to interviews and offers at substantially higher rates. This report explains why many attorneys hesitate to approve firms, why those instincts are costly, and how BCG’s placement model turns approvals into results without sacrificing confidentiality or control.

85% Approximate market coverage (BCG)
75% Hires occur without postings
80% vs 20%Mass vs manual success rate
≈7 days Average time to first interview
Action: Log in and approve firms now. You can always decline interviews later — but you can’t reclaim lost timing. Open My Account

Why Breadth & Speed Win

Public channels (job boards 1–3%, LinkedIn 1–2%) show a fraction of the market and invite heavy competition. Meanwhile, firms hire opportunistically when the right profile appears. Broad approvals let BCG activate multiple pipelines at once — exclusive roles, preferred firms, historical openings, and blind submissions — turning potential demand into interviews quickly.

Market coverage by method Job Boards LinkedIn Other Recruiters BCG ≈85%
BCG covers ≈85% of the market; reactive channels cover 1–3%.
Success Rate: Mass Approval vs Manual Manual (~20%) Mass Approval (~80%) ≈80%
Broad approvals quadruple conversion odds.
Time to First Interview (Mass Approval) ≈7 days avg
Mass Approval accelerates interviews ≈10× vs manual.

Figures reflect BCG’s internal experience and workflow benchmarks and are not guarantees of outcome.

The Ten Reasons — with Fixes

1) Waiting for Posted Jobs Only

The issue: Many attorneys assume that if a role isn’t posted, it doesn’t exist. In practice, firms hire opportunistically when the right profile appears. Public postings represent a minority of actual hiring.

Fix: Approve broadly — especially preferred firms and historical openings. This is where ~75% of hires happen.

Read more: Why Applying Without Openings Works

2) Over‑Selectivity / Perfectionism

The issue: Narrowing to a tiny list of “perfect” firms shrinks your opportunity set and slows progress. The ideal platform may be one you haven’t considered yet.

Fix: Use Mass Approval to explore high‑fit adjacencies (practice/market/firm‑tier). Interviews reveal options no listing can convey.

3) Fear of Rejection

The issue: Holding back to avoid rejection results in fewer at‑bats — paradoxically increasing the risk of a prolonged search.

Fix: Approvals are not commitments; they authorize confidential outreach. You can decline interviews later with zero downside.

4) Confidentiality Concerns

The issue: Worrying about exposure (current employer, clients, counterparties) can cause paralysis.

Fix: BCG honors avoid lists and uses blind submissions where appropriate. We never submit to firms you’ve worked for or recently applied to.

5) Time Constraints / Friction

The issue: Approving one‑by‑one feels slow — so approvals get postponed.

Fix: Enable Mass Approval. We handle positioning, sequencing, and follow‑up within 24–48 hours of approval.

6) Geographic Tunnel Vision

The issue: Limiting to a single micro‑market reduces exposure to active demand.

Fix: Consider adjacent markets or national platforms open to your practice strengths. Breadth ≠ lack of focus; it’s a way to surface better fits faster.

7) Analysis Paralysis

The issue: Endless research without action burns cycles but doesn’t create interviews.

Fix: Approve first, research deeper once an interview is likely. BCG’s firm intelligence and coaching prepare you in context.

8) Resume Isn’t “Perfect” Yet

The issue: Delaying approvals to keep editing materials postpones market feedback.

Fix: Approve now; we refine your materials in parallel and tailor messaging per firm.

9) Early Silence → Giving Up

The issue: If the first few firms don’t respond, candidates assume the market isn’t there.

Fix: Hiring appetite changes weekly. Keep approving. Our sequenced outreach (exclusive → preferred → historical → blind) compounds over time.

10) Misunderstanding What Approval Means

The issue: Some think approval equals a commitment to interview or accept an offer.

Fix: Approval simply authorizes confidential outreach. You retain complete control throughout.

Key takeaway: Approving broadly is the safest, fastest way to learn where you’re strongest in the market — and to unlock opportunities you won’t see posted.

Your Approval Playbook

Step 1 — Approve Broadly (Today)

  • Approve all exclusive roles and preferred firms in your queue.
  • Add historical openings and high‑signal adjacencies.
  • Enable Mass Approval if you’re time‑limited.

Step 2 — Let BCG Move (24–48 Hours)

  • We tailor materials and submit to approved firms.
  • We sequence outreach and follow up with decision‑makers.

Step 3 — Iterate Weekly

  • Approve new firms and adjacencies each week.
  • Use interviews to calibrate target firm profiles.
Approvals vs Interviews Few approvals → low signal Breadth reveals hidden demand Interviews accelerate
More approved firms → more at‑bats → faster interviews.

Ready to unlock the hidden market?

Log in now and approve firms. Submissions typically occur within 24–48 hours.

Open My Account

Case Studies & Testimonials

Case Study: Phoenix Litigation Associate

Problem: Few responses via job boards; selective approvals.

BCG Approach: Mass Approval to 200+ firms; prioritized preferred firms with recent litigation hires; expanded to historical and blind submissions.

  • 6 interviews in 3 weeks
  • Offer from boutique with trial exposure
  • ~35% salary increase

Case Study: Energy Partner, Mountain West

Problem: Concern about confidentiality and portability.

BCG Approach: Blind submissions to avoid conflicts; targeted firms with regulatory growth; staged approvals.

  • 2 offers in 5 weeks
  • Improved rate structure and platform support
“BCG surfaced firms I’d never have found. Three interviews in two weeks.” — Litigation Associate, NYC
“Mass Approval led to five interviews and two offers. I chose a boutique with a faster partner track.” — Corporate EC/VC, SF
“No posted openings, yet BCG created a role by targeting likely‑fit firms.” — Regulatory Counsel, DC
“The hidden market is real. Approving widely changed everything.” — Patent Associate, LA

FAQs & Objections

“Will my employer find out?”

No. We honor your avoid list and use blind submissions when appropriate. We never submit you to firms you’ve worked for or recently applied to.

“Do approvals commit me to interviewing?”

No. Approvals authorize confidential outreach only. You remain in control at every step and can decline interviews or offers.

“I don’t have time to approve dozens of firms.”

Use Mass Approval. We do the heavy lifting and submit within 24–48 hours.

“What if I don’t hear back right away?”

Hiring appetite changes weekly. Keep approving. Our sequenced outreach compounds over time and surfaces new demand as it appears.

Further Reading

Statistics reflect BCG’s internal experience and methodology; they illustrate our model’s advantages and are not guarantees of outcome.

Next Steps

Approve broadly to accelerate your search

The sooner you approve, the faster we submit — including to firms without public postings.

Log In & Approve Firms